When someone gets hurt and another party is at fault, the legal terms used to describe the claim can make a big difference. Two concepts that often get confused are “premises liability” and “personal liability.”
While they may sound similar, they apply to different types of negligence and situations. Understanding the difference between premises liability and personal liability is key if you’re pursuing a claim in Savannah or defending against one.
What Is Premises Liability?
Premises liability deals specifically with injuries that occur on someone else’s property. The core question is whether the property owner failed to maintain safe conditions and whether that failure caused the injury.
This category includes:
- Slip and fall accidents in stores or restaurants
- Falls caused by broken stairs or railings
- Injuries from poor lighting or a lack of security
- Swimming pool accidents
- Dog bites on private property
Under Georgia law, property owners owe a duty of care to people who are lawfully on their property. This duty varies based on the legal status of the visitor: invitee, licensee, or trespasser. Business owners, for example, owe the highest duty to invitees—people invited onto the property for mutual benefit, such as customers.
If a store fails to clean up a spill and a customer slips and breaks a wrist, that’s a textbook premises liability case. The claim targets the property owner or whoever was in control of the space.
What Is Personal Liability?
Personal liability is broader. It refers to an individual being held legally responsible for causing harm to someone else, regardless of where it happens.
This can include:
- Car accidents
- Assaults or intentional torts
- Professional malpractice
- Negligent actions while off-duty or on personal time
In a personal liability claim, the issue isn’t the condition of property—it’s whether a person failed to act with reasonable care. A driver who runs a red light and causes a crash could be personally liable. So could a dog owner whose pet bites someone at a park.
Personal liability claims often lead to insurance claims, especially under auto or homeowner’s policies. But if the conduct is egregious or not covered, the defendant may be on the hook directly.
Key Legal Differences
Though both types of claims involve negligence, the key differences lie in the legal theories and insurance implications.
- Premises liability is tied to property ownership or control. It requires showing that the property was unsafe and that the owner knew or should have known about the hazard.
- Personal liability focuses on an individual’s conduct, regardless of property conditions.
In some cases, both may apply. For example, if someone invites a guest over, leaves a large spill on the floor, and watches the guest fall without warning them, the claim could fall under both categories: premises liability for unsafe conditions, and personal liability for failing to act reasonably.
How Georgia Law Handles These Claims
Georgia applies comparative negligence to both types of cases. That means a plaintiff’s recovery is reduced by their share of fault. If the injured party is 50% or more at fault, they can’t recover anything under Georgia law.
In a premises liability case, defendants often argue that the plaintiff should have seen the hazard and avoided it. In a personal liability case, they may argue that the plaintiff’s actions contributed to the incident.
Savannah courts will evaluate the facts closely in either situation. Evidence like video footage, accident reports, and witness statements often plays a critical role.
Insurance Coverage Considerations
Both types of liability are often covered by insurance—though in different ways:
- Premises liability is typically addressed by property insurance (e.g., homeowners or business liability policies).
- Personal liability may be covered by auto insurance, renters insurance, or umbrella policies.
If insurance doesn’t apply—or if the claim exceeds policy limits—the defendant may be personally responsible for paying damages.
Knowing the Difference Protects Your Rights
Understanding the distinction between premises liability and personal liability is crucial when pursuing compensation or defending a claim in Georgia. Each involves different legal standards, responsibilities, and types of insurance coverage.
Whether you’ve been injured in a slip and fall or harmed by someone’s careless actions, recognizing which type of claim applies can make a significant difference in the outcome of your case. If you’re unsure, speaking with an experienced Savannah personal injury attorney can help you navigate your options and build a strong case.
Contact Bowen Painter Injury Lawyers for a free consultation.
Contact the Personal Injury Law Firm of Bowen Painter Injury Lawyers in Savannah for Help Today
For more information, please contact our experienced Savannah personal injury lawyer at Bowen Painter Injury Lawyers to schedule a free initial consultation today. We have a convenient location in Savannah, GA.
We proudly serve Chatham County, Georgia, and its surrounding areas.
Bowen Painter Injury Lawyers
308 Commercial Drive, Suite 100, Savannah, GA 31406
(912) 335-1909
Open 24/7
